u3a

St Ives (Cambs)

Oct 2026: The Eights by Joanna Miller

The Eights' by Joanna Miller was described as a 'fireside book', a book for 'bedtime', an 'easy read', a book to read for 'pleasure', referencing the name of the group; however this took us, once again, into what 'Reading for Pleasure' means; some in the group found it not 'pleasurable' due to its lack of depth in the subject matter, together with the predictability of the characters and storyline

The subject and historical context, all agreed, was interesting but some felt the author could have developed further some aspects, thereby weaving the historical aspects of the book more into the storyline as opposed to history, at times, sitting separate to it.

The characters in the book were viewed as a little 'predictable' both in their backgrounds and behaviours; it was not felt that any one character of 'The Eights' compelled the reader to feel invested in their story. Marianne was cited as an example of this with her 'circumstance' feeling a little drawn out and expected when revealed at the end of the book.

More 'meat on the bone' was an expression used in regard to the book, however all agreed the possibility from the overview of the history within the book, other novels such as a 'Testament of Youth' Vera Britain would enhance this if required. If the history had been more detailed, could this have changed the 'target audience' for the book?

The book did not 'allow' the depth of discussion from previous books, nor such differing responses to a book as other authors have; this led to a shorter discussion with an overall view of the book as a 'comfortable' but not 'challenging' read. The overall score of 6.5 reflected this.